I finally received my Juliana Hatfield album yesterday. I listened to it last night and I can't say I was too impressed. There were a few stand out tracks, but overall I'd say not even as many as on her last album, Made In China. The one really great thing about it is that I pre-ordered the version that came with a disc of demos from the sessions of making this album. The studio album only has 10 tracks, and not even all of them are on the demo CD, and the demo CD has 20 tracks. I like most of the demo versions of the tracks from the new album SO much better. I think it's mostly because I really enjoy the crunchy, laid back, casual Juliana, and the gloss of having some fancy producer just doesn't seem to suit her. I've heard some critics are saying it's her best work yet, but I can't say I agree in the least. It's not awful, but it's not the Juliana I love.
Then today I was listening to my iTunes on random and Ben Folds Five's "Song For the Dumped" came on...and I should note, the version I keep on my iTunes is a demo version, and not the album version, and I thought "damn, this demo is way better than the album version too"...so then, of course I started to think "what other songs I like are like that?" I came up with a few, and yes, I realize my affinity for folk, acoustic and simple music is probably why I generally like demos better, but not always. So here are a few I came up with...
Demos I like better than album-versions:Juliana Hatfield - "Shining On"The album version just sounds like "adult contemporary" blah to me, really. It's ok, but is a bit of a yawn. The demo is just much more light-hearted and simple, it reminds me a lot more of the Juliana I love.
(
album version)
(
demo version)
Ben Folds Five - "Song For the Dumped"The demo is so much better for this song because the song is a song by a bitter boyfriend who's just been dumped, and as one would expect him to be, he's irate and throwing all kinds of things in her face...but the album version is too clean, too nice, too poppy somehow, the demo version definitely fills the bill better and makes you cheer the guy on more. The difference might only be one line, but the line packs the punch I think the song really needs somehow. My guess is the record label told them to clean it up a bit for the album. Lame.
(
album version)
(
demo version)
Lisa Loeb - "Dance With The Angels"I was a huge fan of Lisa Loeb back in the day...obsessed with Tails, and I still love the album, but Lisa has been hit or miss since then unfortunately. BUT, her demo tape "The Purple Tape" was recently just released on CD and it's really great. Before her demo tape though, she was in a band in college with her roommate Liz Mitchell (now of the band Ida) and they recorded two demo albums together as Liz & Lisa. A number of the songs Lisa wrote with Liz she has since re-recorded for albums, including about half of Tails. But I was really disappointed when she put a new version of "Dance With the Angels" on "Firecracker", because it just can't hold a candle to the one she did in college.
(
album version)
(
demo version)
Brandi Carlile - "Throw It All Away"Before Brandi released her self-titled album, she released an EP featuring some of the songs that would later appear on her first album. The EP was simply called "Acoustic" as it was recorded live and was all acoustic and very stripped down. For a while her song "Throw it all Away" from that EP was available for free on her website and that was my first taste of her. I was sorely disappointed when the album version wasn't nearly as powerful or beautiful as the heart-wrenching acoustic version, which I had loved so much that I played it repeatedly after I discovered it.
(
album version)
(
demo version)
Jewel - "Love Me, Just Leave Me Alone"When Jewel's first album came out she was a breath of fresh air for most people. But a bunch of that first album was recorded live, and since then her albums have gotten more and more produced and taken away the charm of what that first album was. I liked her so much at the time that I bought bootleg CDs of live performances, TV performances or whatever the local store had (yes, this was before the internet). For a lot of the songs, the live versions were a lot better than her album ones, if only because they felt more real, and like she wasn't trying so hard...not to mention she did a lot more fun and/or goofy songs live too to get the crowd going. On one of these old bootlegs (from a 1996 performance) she performed a "new song" called "Love Me, Just Leave Me Alone" and I thought it was great, really fun. Then on her 2001 album "This Way" she did a studio recording of the same song and I really didn't care for it at all. Somehow when she played it live it lost it's charm and what was fun then just seemed contrived and awkward. It's not really a "demo" since it was live, but it WAS a version that pre-dated the album one, and therefore I think it counts.
(
album version)
(
live/demo version)